Rated 5 out of
5
by
Katrina Lahood from
I don't leave my house without this eyeliner. No kidding! It's amazing and I'm so glad my work colleague introduced us! It is the only eyeliner I can apply without making a mess, and I'm always left with flawless results (no thanks to my handiwork, I'm sure). The tip is so sharp and soft so you have COMPLETE control - which means you can create the perfect wing with your desired thickness without stuffing it up! With it, I have mastered the winged look - thin and elegant for everyday at the office, and heavy and stretched out for a night out. I love it and HIGHLY recommend it!
Date published: 2016-06-20
Rated 1 out of
5
by
winged eyeliner drama from
I remember it being better
I habitually wear winged eyeliner as daily makeup, and I remember this particular eyeliner as being a favorite of mine in high school. Be it makeup quality or just change in preference, something has changed for me. The brush is small and flimsy, not good for precision. And if you mess up, the quick drying formula makes it difficult to get off without irritating the skin.
Once the product is fully dry, it pulls into itself and looks creased on your upper eye lid, exaggerating lines you may have. While this product is meant to withstand water, over the course of the day you can expect bits to flake off without even touching.
Very disappointed.
Date published: 2018-02-02
Rated 1 out of
5
by
ashvrem from
unhappy results
I've been wanting a smug and water proof eyeliner and decided to go with Maybelline. I bought both the black and brown shades and tried them both out for several days. I did a swatch test and yes, they are both smug and water resistant; however, the liner cracks while on the eyelid if slightly tugged and will flake off all over the place if you are not careful. It was also really hard to remove in my opinion. This was even with the waterproof eye makeup remover Maybelline offers. Thank goodness my drugstore takes makeup returns! I returned the makeup today for a full refund and will not be purchasing it again. Despite not liking the liquid liner formula, I did like the precision brush and recommend Maybelline continue to use that style for future products. Just give us girls a non-flaky liner to go with it. :)
Date published: 2013-01-09
Rated 1 out of
5
by
JoNatural from
Was the best Eyeliner out there !
I loved this eyeliner. I adored the taupe shade because it lined the eye beautifully giving it a natural looking effect without the harshness like the black and very dark brown. This shade defined the eye without making it look overly made up. Please bring this color back. The black and brown are too close in color and alot of women would prefer the natural beauty of this shade. Please bring this shade back, and also the formula of the orignal ultra liner waterproof liguid eyeliner !
The shades and formula is was set this eyeliner apart from the rest. This was a leader.
Date published: 2017-03-02
Rated 1 out of
5
by
Ozette from
Awful! Bring back the original...
I've been using your waterproof liner for years. But you've clearly changed the formula. Like other unhappy posters -- who outnumber fans of this liner, you will notice-- I also found that once it dries, it starts to flake and is nearly impossible to take off. I've tried Clinique, Trish McEvoy and Lancôme removers as well as coconut oil and baby shampoo. I threw out three tubes thinking they must be old, but the new ones-- brown and black -- are even worse. You keep saying the formula is unchanged but dozens of us beg to differ.
Date published: 2017-02-28
Rated 1 out of
5
by
Steph Lyn from
UGH...WHAT HAPPENED??
I’m not sure what happened to this product, but it is a disaster!
The bottle that it comes in is now so cheap, that when you open the product, the inside portion of the container comes out and creates a giant mess (not to mention that it wastes a good portion of the actual eyeliner).
Black seems to be the only color available these days – the lighter colors would be welcomed back by many.
And the texture seems to have changed. It is very flaky. It seems nearly impossible to create a clean line along the lashes (perhaps that has to do with the poorly designed bottle?). It always seems to look clumpy.
The eyeliner used to be sold with a cap and the brush/cap on the side…about the time the packaging changed is when I noticed a huge decline in quality.
Date published: 2017-06-28
Rated 1 out of
5
by
Galaxy815 from
Formula change?
What happened? I have now bought two bottles of this product which I love and have used for 10 yrs.... and it's so watery and light! It used to be nice and thick and now it feels like a totally different product. Please bring back your old formula! It was my fav and go-to daily eye liner.... :(
Date published: 2016-11-26
Rated 3 out of
5
by
Deder from
Changing of products... :-(
For over 20 years I used your similar eyeliner in the white and black bottle. It was a liquid liner that dried on the waterline of the eye and lasted all day!!! Never has there been such a product since. I understand changes, but that one killed me.
Date published: 2016-07-28
